ULTRASONIC TESTING OF TUBE - PHASED ARRAY TECHNIQUE - NO
MECHANICAL ROTATION
2. Project description or technological area of interest
Tube inspection is currently performed using complex and
heavy mechanical systems where different probes are set to
rotate very fast (6000 to 8000 rpm/min.) around a tube that
has been given an axial movement. This system lacks
sensitivity, is difficult to maintain and expensive. It
therefore reduces productivity.
The innovation of this project lies in the use of a
technique based on phased array technologies. From
transducers fixed around the tube and circling it,
sound pulses - according to a preset pattern - are sent
towards the tube wall during its axial movement. This very
fast rotation does not induce any mechanical constraint on
the probe.
This technology allows the operator to inspect the tubes
automatically, by means of information given
permanently by a software program, concerning the detection
of volume or dimension defects; inspection performed
according to quality assurance requirements.
The goal is to double the speed of inspection, reduce by
4 the slack period during calibration phases, and reduce
the cost of a system by 25% (now around 770,000 ECU).
The application fields are mainly:
* nuclear manufacturing (steam generator and fuel tubes),
* metallurgy,
* petrochemistry and chemical manufacturing (reactors and
exchanger tubes),
* automotive engineering and,
* the aircraft industry.
Inspections are carried out on an impressive amount of
tubes manufactured by those industrial areas to guarantee a
level of quality (as far as both defect as well as
dimension-related aspects are concerned).
This new technology enables a new field to be supplied.
Services in the nuclear business are now so important that
they require ultrasonic testing of tubes by external means
(fueltube, grape tube): new materials used inside nuclear
power plants do not react well to Eddy Currents.
Due to this new technology,the user can connect the probe
to a simple mechanism in order to inspect radiated tubes
easily.
The commercial perspectives are quite good. First, the
extent of the industrial fields interested in this
technology is important; then more and more customers -
mainly from Western Europe - are increasing the quality of
their manufacturing process to compete with countries with
low labour costs. In other respects, this technology
allows them to control their manufacturing process in order
to reduce production losses thereby increasing the added
value and enhancing their own technology.
The industrial perspectives are also quite good. This
technology transfers complexity from the mechanical to the
electronic field, making it able to produce significant
industrialisation processes, mainly for numerous repetitive
functions and when mechanical devices encounter physical
limits.
Thus, the electronic system will manage between 1000 and
2000 channels. Mass production for only one system allows
advanced industrialisation processes associating
performances, reliability and low costs to be considered.
3. Participants
Main :
FRANCE
- NDT SYSTEMS
Partners :
SWEDEN
- SANDVIK STEEL AB
- TSONIC
4. Main contact
NDT SYSTEMS
MR. DOMINIQUE BRACONNIER
Dept. :
Funct.: GENERAL MANAGER
Addr. : AVENUE DU TELEPORT, FUTUROSCOPE
B.P. 118
863 60 CHASSENEUIL DU POITOU
FRANCE
Tel : +33 5 49 49 42 10
Fax : +33 5 49 49 00 19
Telex :
5. Estimated costs
Total project cost : 2.37 MECU
6. Timescale
Start date : JUN 1996
End date : JUN 1998
Duration : 24 months
FEASIBILITY PHASE : JUN 1996 - SEP 1996 3 months
DEFINITION PHASE : SEP 1996 - DEC 1996 3 months
RESEARCH STAGE : NOV 1996 - MAY 1997 6 months
DEVELOPMENT STAGE : MAY 1997 - NOV 1997 6 months
INITIAL EXPLOITATION : NOV 1997 - FEB 1998 3 months
FULL EXPLOITATION : FEB 1998 - MAY 1998 3 months
7. Technological developments envisaged
Various technological developments are envisaged.
As far as probes are concerned, it is important to define a
standard in order to decrease the cost within the project.
The shape and geometrical definition of probes will be
optimised, using piezocomposite technologies. Probes will
consist of arrays circling the tube. Another aspect
involves the sensitivity which can, if it is very good,
greatly simplify the electronics and therefore reduce
costs.
As for the probe head, a special acoustic-mechanical device
will also be developed, based on work already done with
simulating tools. This constitutes a major aspect if the
productivity has to be optimised and the costs of products
reduced. Acoustic paths, the relative position of probes,
ways to insert tubes and water will be optimised.
Materials will also be studied with a view to improving
reliability, longevity, immunity to changes in temperature
and performance.
As far as electronics are concerned, the technological
development will mainly involve integration (ability to
manage more than 1000 channels to manage arrays), working
with analogue, high frequency and high dynamics.
Concerning digital parts, the latest version of FPGA will
be integrated to get very high clock frequency (and
consequently very good accuracy) and a high degree of
integration.
Interfaces working on the PCI bus standard will be used to
work with advanced technologies. High data flux will then
benefit the product and enable advanced software functions
with great amounts of data to be used.
As for software technology, it is envisaged to develop
oriented component software, able to use libraries to
evolve and assist maintenance.
Another new factor is the ability to work with digital
data, not only for the configuration and management of the
tools, but also to manage signal data. With acquired data,
working in digital mode, it is possible to considerably
influence inspection and management attitudes. It is
possible to integrate directly the information of the
different resume and report. Instead of storing data on
thermal paper, which is very expensive and difficult to
work with (many customers spend each year more than 70,000
ECU on such paper), it will now be possible to use CD or
similar media.
Multiprocessor hardware working with multi-tasks
workstation will be used. The main advantage will reside
with its powerful nature and the possibility for
customers to implement for themselves special automation
systems connected to software, but without there being any
risks involved in terms of maintainability, because it is a
disconnected task.
8. Relationship to other European technological co-operation programmes
NON
Unknown relationship
9. Financial or other contribution of each participant to the project
FRANCE : 51 %
- NDT SYSTEMS
Will develop the instrumentation part and act as the manager
of the whole project.
SWEDEN : 48 %
- SANDVIK STEEL AB
Its contribution will relate to production and inspection
applications as it is quite essential to be able to qualify
the product after having perfectly defining and designed as
we can benefit from bench tests to fulfil maximum needs.
- TSONIC
Will provide general scientific support as well as develop
and design the software tools required. Later it will
develop software and support the design and qualification of
testing procedures.
10. Relevant qualifications of participants
NDT SYSTEMS
This company provides high performance equipment on the non
destructive testing (NDT) market field. Its main
competence in acoustics, electronics and software is well
known.
It has two ranges of product (representing over 30
products), the first based on conventional technologies but
with open and modular architecture, the second based on
phrased array technology.
NDT SYSTEMS has many customers in Europe as well as America
and JAPAN such as: VALLOUREC, CEZUS, GENERAL ELECTRIC,
MITSUI ENGINEERING & SHIPBUILDING, SAQ, etc.
It has already developed products for tube inspection
according to conventional technologies. This project will
give NDT the opportunity to implement phased array
techniques, thereby opening up a very interesting market.
It has already developed some similar technologies
involving the inspection of team generator tubes on the
inside.
SANDVIK STEEL AB
This company manufactures tubes for various applications
and its main markets are the petrochemical, nuclear and
automotive industries.
SANDVIK STEEL AB's considerable experience in tube
inspection spans 30 years. The Division in charge of this
project owns more than half a dozen conventional and very
complex systems called ROTA (produced by a project
competitor).
This company is empowered to request changes to the
qualifying standards and procedures usually used in this
field. It has both the means and qualified personnel to
carry out the project developments.
It will be responsible for the application aspect in the
tube manufacturing field.
TSONIC
This is spin-off company related to CIRCUITS & SYSTEMS
GROUP at the UNIVERSITY OF UPPSALA. Although founded quite
recently, it is well known for its work in the
non-destructive testing field, both ultrasonic and eddy
currents. The Group participates in two BRITE EURAM
projects and collaborates with Swedish Industry (SWEDISH
NUCLEAR FUEL AND WASTE MANAGEMENT CO., ABB, SAAB) as well
as international companies (AEROSPATIALE, DASSAULT, IMRA in
FRANCE and TWI in the UNITED KINGDOM).
The company is well known for its expertise in the field of
ultrasonic signal processing, array technology and
ultrasonic modelling. TSONIC has its own ultrasonic array
system which can be used to verify and calibrate the
developed equipment.
The company, together with NDT SYSTEMS (FRANCE), will be
responsible for the scientific part of the project.
11. Status of agreement between participants
The partners are currently studying the agreement which
will mainly cover the relationships between them.
SANDVIK renounces any right to this technology, preferring
to keep the competitive edge it will gain from using it.
PART II : ADDITIONAL MEASURES REQUESTED
12. Additional measures requested
NO SUPPORTIVE MEASURES ARE REQUESTED
- No action specified
13. Competent authorities
NO SUPPORTIVE MEASURES ARE REQUESTED
No authority specified.
14. Authorities responsible for progress report to high level group
NO SUPPORTIVE MEASURES ARE REQUESTED
No authority specified
PART III : OPTIONAL SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
15. Application/market
Two kinds of competitors are known - some rare subsidiaries
of large companies and very small specialised teams. In
both cases, everybody is working according to conventional
technologies: this means single element probes, rotating
mechanically around the tube with very complex and
expensive systems. Some of those companies have been able
to customise their products in a specific field (mainly
nuclear or petrochemicals) but cannot match other
specifications. In all cases, prices cannot be changed,
due to the difficulty in industrialising the mechanical
components.
This market is growing as tubes are used more and more in
the industry and, furthermore, a very important tube
replacement market (NUKEM has already set up almost 150
systems around the world) must be added. Also, due to the
development of ISO standards, customers are increasing
requiring the strict respect of inspection norms.
Another new market concerns the inspection in situ of fuel
tubes. This will increase considerably because of the
changing of materials used, prohibiting the use of eddy
currents.
Both cases indicate that this technology has a lot to offer
lot, firstly in terms of cost and productivity and,
secondly, in ease of use. It also enables sensitivity to
be significantly improved.
The fact that we form a group of equipment manufacturers,
scientists and main companies competent in using this
application provides the main guarantees of success.
We can project a market of more than 300 systems over the
next ten years.
NDT SYSTEMS is interested in selling the largest number
of systems. SANDVIK is interested in taking advantage of
the best part of this new technology, thus putting them
ahead of their competitors as they will acquire superior
expertise in this technology thanks to their active
participation to this project.
16. Location of development work
- NDT SYSTEMS
at CHASSENEUIL DU POITOU - FRANCE
- SANDVIK STEEL AB
at SANDVIKEN - SWEDEN
- TSONIC
at UPPSALA - SWEDEN
17. Where and by whom is development to be exploited initially
- NDT SYSTEMS
- SANDVIK STEEL AB
This project will first be applied by SANDVIK, in the tube
manufacturing field. Secondly, TECNATOM will apply it on
services in situ, once the code has been established. NDT
SYSTEMS will launch it on the market once the qualification
has been agreed upon.
18. Partners sought
No.
More information about EUREKA find on their Home page.
Other projects can be retrieved throught the Access Menu of the Database
©copyright Rolf Diederichs, 01. Febr 1997
/DB:News /DT:Technology /IN:EU /CN:all_europe /CT:UT /CT:transducer /CT:array /CT:steel /ED:1997-2