Forum Technical Discussions Re: EN 10160 interpretation Posted by: bob sudharmin (PID_3396), E-mail: Address, on August 01, 2008 at 16:14 : In Reply to: Re: EN 10160 interpretation posted by : Y.Karavacioglu , E-mail: Address, on August 01, 2008 at 07:57 : Acceptance and rejection criteria are based on agreed boundaries, a draw off line. Like I said earlier, defects of lower than 100mm2 is not to be considered. To answer your query on the size of more than 1000mm2, it is an automatic reject. The code allows not more than 15 in nos of size in-between 100 to 1000mm2 in an area of 1 Meter sq. If you have a single size of more than 1000mm2 in the same area with the 15 in nos, or in another area of the same plate for that matter, you no longer have to even consider the 15, since that single defect is above the permissible range. Trust this clarifies. ----------- Start Original Message ----------- : Dear Bobsudharmin, : Think the other condition : if there is 15 defects in this range and also there is some defect that's sizes is higher than 1000mm². At this condition this plate is acceptable or not ? : Thank you : : Isn't the statement clear enough? Defects of size less than 100mm2 is not to be considered. The criteria would be ACCEPT if it does not exceed 15 in nos. : : : : best regards, : : bobsudharmin : : : : : Dear Expert; : : : We work on UT test for plate. : : : For EN 10160 class S1; : : : standard say permisible defect size and number of defects are following : : : : Area : : : Defect mm² Max. number of defects : : : Within 1 m² : : : 100 - 1000 15 : : : My question is if there is 15 defects in this range and also there is some defect that's sizes is lower than 100mm². At this condition this plate is acceptable or not ? : : : Thank you ------------ End Original Message ------------ Follow Ups: Post a Followup: Name: E-Mail: Subject: Comments: ----------- Start Original Message ----------- : Acceptance and rejection criteria are based on agreed boundaries, a draw off line. Like I said earlier, defects of lower than 100mm2 is not to be considered. To answer your query on the size of more than 1000mm2, it is an automatic reject. The code allows not more than 15 in nos of size in-between 100 to 1000mm2 in an area of 1 Meter sq. : If you have a single size of more than 1000mm2 in the same area with the 15 in nos, or in another area of the same plate for that matter, you no longer have to even consider the 15, since that single defect is above the permissible range. : Trust this clarifies. : : Dear Bobsudharmin, : : Think the other condition : : if there is 15 defects in this range and also there is some defect that's sizes is higher than 1000mm². At this condition this plate is acceptable or not ? : : Thank you : : : Isn't the statement clear enough? Defects of size less than 100mm2 is not to be considered. The criteria would be ACCEPT if it does not exceed 15 in nos. : : : : : : best regards, : : : bobsudharmin : : : : : : : Dear Expert; : : : : We work on UT test for plate. : : : : For EN 10160 class S1; : : : : standard say permisible defect size and number of defects are following : : : : : Area : : : : Defect mm² Max. number of defects : : : : Within 1 m² : : : : 100 - 1000 15 : : : : My question is if there is 15 defects in this range and also there is some defect that's sizes is lower than 100mm². At this condition this plate is acceptable or not ? : : : : Thank you ------------ End Original Message ------------ Optional Link URL: Example: "http://www....html". Alternative write "http://www.ndt.net/wshop/attach/filename.htm" if you transfered a filename.htm via FTP Page Title: is important! Optional Image URL: http://www....gif Attention! Please click the button only once. This may take a moment to process Forum Technical Discussions Help