International Symposium (NDT-CE 2003)Non-Destructive Testing in Civil Engineering 2003
|Start > Contributions >Lectures > Corrosion:|
A multi-dipole mobile array for the non-destructive evaluation of pavement and concrete infrastructures: a feasability study.Michel Chouteau, Ecole Polytechnique-CERCA, Montreal, Canada
Sébastien Vallières, Ecole Polytechnique, Montreal, Canada
Edgar Toe, Ecole Polytechnique, Montreal, Canada
Concrete used for bridge decks, road pavements and other transportation facilities experience loss of integrity over time caused by poor initial quality, action of de-icing salts, temperature changes, fatigue and, above all, delamination caused by corrosion of reinforcement bars. Also poor support from the subgrade layer can cause significant problems to the concrete slab. Electrical resistivity is sensitive to those losses of integrity. Poor initial quality reduces compressive strength and causes low bulk electrical resistivity. Chlorides can also penetrate concrete and drastically reduce resistivity; in turn, lower resistivity accelerates corrosion of rebars. The method has been tested on a bridge deck in Montreal and compared with other geophysical and geotechnical data. The results were encouraging; however acquisition was very slow and time-consuming. Traffic must be closed to perform the survey. In order to fully make the method operational and flexible for NDE, we have investigated the development of a multi-dipole mobile array. A compromise between resolution, depth of investigation and dipole combination must be found.
Using 3D numerical modeling we first examine resistivity responses associated with the various problems mentioned above that affects concrete. In the case of rebars, differences occur if they are corroded or not and if cracking and/or delamination is taking place; resistivity anisotropy is also indicative of rebar distribution. The system is also very sensitive to fine cracks that develops over the concrete surface and to internal defects. The system can also acurately estimate asphalt thickness and characterize the condition of the subgrade layer supporting the concrete slab in case of paved roads. The system has been tested in the lab over concrete slabs simulating various conditions. Results suggest good agreement with numerical modelling data. Finally we suggest future development in data acquisition and interpretation with this NDT system.
The use of the resistivity method for non-destructive testing (NDT) of concrete structures has been very limited until now. Cabasut et al (1997) have investigated loss of integrity of water pipes by conducting resistivity surveys inside. Usually the method is slow because of the physical contact of electrodes with the material under investigation. The contact may be difficult to achieve and when concrete is involved special techniques must be use to penetrate the material. Also engineers will rely more on mechanical properties (seismic, sonic methods) than electrical resistivity to diagnose problems. On another hand, non-seismic methods like GPR would be much faster to perform surveys and generally resolve the geometry better. However, preliminary studies using numerical and scale modeling (Chouteau et al, 2002) demonstrated the potential of the method. A resistivity tomographic survey carried out in 1999 over an aging overpass in Montreal was able to successfully map quality of concrete and determine the position of rebars (Chouteau et al, 2000?). It was soon realized that for investigating highway concrete infrastructures the method was very slow and was confronted to high contact impedances in case of carbonated concrete surfaces and asphalt cover. Resistivity measurements had to be done in a continuous mode and fast. Capacitively-coupled resistivity systems would be the solution. Such systems already exits for a few years (Corim, from IRIS; OhmMapper from Geometrics, MPR-2R developed by University of Paris). The concepts can be found in Grard & Tabbagh (1991), Tabbagh et al (1993) and Panissod et al (1998). However they are not used for NDT of concrete and not adapted in anyway to those applications. It was therefore decided to study the performance of a electrostatic system designed especially to map various factors affecting integrity of concrete structures. As a compromise has to be found between depth of investigation and resolution we came with the concept of a wheel train of dipoles (figure 1) that could be used either in in-line or equatorial modes. The first dipole transmits a AC current (frequency in the kHz's). The remaining dipoles are receiver potential dipoles. The distances between the poles are from 5 cm to 20 cm. The total length is between 1,0 to 2,5 m.
It has been shown (Tabbagh et al, 1993) that for the quasi-static case and low induction number, the resistance measured is the same as would measured the DC resistivity method. Therefore in the following presentation all results have been obtained from 3D DC resistivity modeling.
There are many factors that could affect integrity of concrete and reduce its compressive strength: initial composition, corrosion of rebars leading to cracking, scaling, delamination. The compressive strength is dependant on the water/cement ratio. The higher the ratio the lower is the strength. Electrical resistivity of concrete decreases almost linearly with increasing water/cement ratio for a given cement content (Neville, 1998) and therefore resistivity can be diagnostic of the compressive strength. Electric current is conducted through moist concrete by ions (electrolytic mechanism). Figure 2 shows the resistivity response with curing time for three concrete slabs with two differing water/cement ratio and compressive strength.
Progress of corrosion of steel reinforcement is controlled by the electrical resistivity of concrete and therefore it is better to maintain high resistivities within the concrete. Addition of chloride ions originating from de-icing salts for example will decrease electrical resistivity and accelerate the generation of corrosion. Studies have shown that for resistivities lower than 100 Wm risk of corrosion are high while it is negligible for values higher than 1000 Wm.
Experiments have shown that bulk electrical resistivity of concrete is dependant upon its integrity (Cabasut et al, 1997). Damages can vary from cracking, spalling and delamination induced by steel reinforcement corrosion to scaling caused by weathering (frost-thaw). Presence of water or not in the cracks will modify the bulk resistivity of the material.
Therefore, loss of integrity, chloride ions and compressive strength will affect resistivity of concrete and a method based on the mapping of the resistivity distribution will help diagnose defects in concrete structures.
Numerical modelling and imaging
In order to provide diagnostic information about the concrete structure the method must be sensitive to change in concrete integrity. Here we will show how the method responds to concrete slabs and reinforced bars, corrosion, de-icing salts, cracks, defects, asphalt thickness and also how well theybe imaged.
Concrete slab and rebars
Using 2D resistivity inversion for the modelled data, the resistivity of concrete and the depth to the rebars are well resolved Figure 4). The rebars show up as a conductive layer. Below, resistivity rises caused by the resistivity of concrete and then the air.
Severe rebar corrosion may cause delamination of concrete. Then an air filled resistive horizontal crack develops at the rebar level that shows up as a resistive layer in the interpreted model (figure 5) compared to a conductive layer when no delamination takes place (figure 4).
Heterogeneous subgrade layer
Testing on concrete slab models
Bulk electrical resistivity of concrete is dependant on (1) the intrinsic quality of concrete (composition, compressive strength), (2) the condition of surfacial/volumic deterioration caused by cracking, delamination and salts, and (3) the distribution of reinforcement bars within the concrete structure. Using numerical modeling and imaging, we have shown that the resistivity method can be used to map corrosion potential (resistivity of concrete), vertical cracks, delamination, defects and asphalt thickness. helping diagnose possible damage. Experiments on bridge decks and concrete slabs show that the method is applicable and could help diagnose the state of concrete structures; however a new generation of NDT equipment needs to be developed to expedite surveys over transportation structures.