where expertise comes together - since 1996 -

The Largest Open Access Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)

Conference Proceedings, Articles, News, Exhibition, Forum, Network and more

where expertise comes together
- since 1996 -

IMG ULTRASUONI SRL
Ultrasonic transducers for industrial applications (NDT) and medical (Doppler effect). Probes, Ultrasonic instruments, Special systems for NDT.

4207 views
Technical Discussions
Nigel Armstrong
Engineering, - Specialist services
United Kingdom, Joined Oct 2000, 1094

Nigel Armstrong

Engineering, - Specialist services
United Kingdom,
Joined Oct 2000
1094
07:58 Jun-06-2007
ASME ultrasonic calibration blocks

The attached link is to an US company (Ray-Check) offering a set of alternative ASME calibration blocks manufactured in accordance with the Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI), PDI-UT-1, Rev C (ferritic) and PD-UT-2, Rev C (austenitic).

A previous thread on ndt.net demonstrated the increased(unmanageable?) range of pipe calibration blocks required since the 2002 issue where Article 4 became Ultrasonic Examination of Welds:

http://www.ndt.net/wshop/forum/messages-1/9645.html

Ray-Check claim: "These cover the generic procedures for the ultrasonic examination of both ferritic and austenitic pipe welds. The blocks offer an economical alternative to fabricating multiple curved calibration blocks (pipe sections) in numerous diameters and wall thicknesses."

How can a set of 3 blocks (ferritic, 304 and 316 I believe) replace all those pipe nominal sizes and schedules supposedly required by T-434.3. I realise ASME is a pressure vessel rather than a piping code but unfortunately the piping codes (B31.3 and B31.4) specify use of ASME V and I can see no word in that document alowing use of these notched blocks. Even B31.3 Code Case 181 and ASME V Code Case 2235-9 require the manufacture of a qualification block of "the same product form, and material specification or equivalent P-Number grouping as one of the materials being examined. Has anyone experience with these "alternative blocks" iaw the PDI. Was this PDI run at EPRI? Why is there no mention of it in updates to ASME, how is anybody going ot learn about it apart from As our German colleagues say "reine Zufall".

I would be grateful for any enlightenment anybody can offer.





    
 
 
Aaron
Aaron
12:49 Feb-11-2014
Re: ASME ultrasonic calibration blocks
In Reply to Nigel Armstrong at 07:58 Jun-06-2007 (Opening).

I am hoping to revive this post and see if anyone out there has any insight on these blocks. I have not been able to find any ASME code cases that allow for the direct use of these. Also, where can you find the full PDI-UT-1, and -2? I have contacted a few of the manufacturers that are selling these blocks for more information and have not received any response back on. Any feedback would be appreciated. I also know that if I was to qualify these blocks individually on a job by job basis that they would be allowed, but I am trying to save time and money, so I am really looking for any documents that will allow the direct use of these alternative blocks. http://www.flawtech.com/proddetail.asp?prod=PDI-CB-4 Thanks everyone.

Aaron

    
 
 
Jason Witts
NDT Inspector,
Canada, Joined May 2011, 5

Jason Witts

NDT Inspector,
Canada,
Joined May 2011
5
19:49 Feb-11-2014
Re: ASME ultrasonic calibration blocks
In Reply to Aaron at 12:49 Feb-11-2014 .

The short answer would be no, these blocks would not be allowed according to code. For stainless steels not only should you have cal blocks of the same diameter/thickness of piece to be inspected.
You should also be demonstrating the system capabilities on a specimen welded according to the WPS used on the specific project.

    
 
 
John
John
03:32 Feb-12-2014
Re: ASME ultrasonic calibration blocks
In Reply to Jason Witts at 19:49 Feb-11-2014 .

Looked into those a few yrs back. Cannot use according to ASME the last time I checked. The word "SHALL" I believe applies in this situation.
Regards

    
 
 
Aaron
NDT Inspector,
USA, Joined Feb 2014, 1

Aaron

NDT Inspector,
USA,
Joined Feb 2014
1
13:07 Feb-12-2014
Re: ASME ultrasonic calibration blocks
In Reply to John at 03:32 Feb-12-2014 .

Thanks for the feedback. I thought these were too good to be true. However, I would love to see these PDI-UT-1 & 2 procedures to see what they are all about. What I don't understand is if the nuclear world (NRC and EPRI) have approved these through the performance demonstration initiative, why has ASME not made a code case about them. Nuclear inspections are to ASME section XI so if they are using these how are they not approved for regular ASME section V work of the same type (pipe butt welds). Also, if they are in use how is there not a code case about them? How are these companies getting away with selling these as an alternative to the standard ASME piping calibration blocks we all love so much. Has anyone seen these in use or know anyone that has used them? Still curious and hoping someone can provide more information on these. Thanks again.
Aaron

    
 
 
Ed Ginzel
R & D, -
Materials Research Institute, Canada, Joined Nov 1998, 1228

Ed Ginzel

R & D, -
Materials Research Institute,
Canada,
Joined Nov 1998
1228
15:22 Feb-12-2014
Re: ASME ultrasonic calibration blocks
In Reply to John at 03:32 Feb-12-2014 .

Since Nigel posted this item in 2007 until now there has been a change in ASME Section V. In 2010 the paragraph T-434.3 Piping Calibration Blocks; describes how the basic calibration block configuration and reflectors shall be as shown in Fig. T-434.3.
But then departs from the old requirements to match schedule and allows curvature in accordance with T-434.1.7 and thickness ±25% of the nominal thickness of the component.
In a general way I echo John's statement about SHALL, however, ASME's statements concerning "shall" do not always mean mandatory. For example, T-434.4.1 states that the basic calibration blocks SHALL be as shown in Fig. T-434.4.1. Then in the very next paragraph T-434.4.2 provides for an alternative block. It is difficult to understand the term SHALL in the normal way that standards are written when it is accompanied by the concept of "or". This is seen in a few places in Section V. E.g. T-434.1.1 specified reflectors "SHALL" be used. Then in the next sentence they allow that an alternative be used.

1    
 
 

Product Spotlight

FlexoFORM™

The FlexoFORM™ solution integrates flexible phased array probe technology in a scanner to solv
...
e the challenges that come with inspecting pipe elbows. When combined with a water column, this solution can be used to collect easy-to-interpret data on elbows with diameters ranging from 4.5 in. OD up to flat and offers many benefits.
>

Ultrasonic Flaw Detector & Thickness Gauge: Smartor

SIUI’s newly launched Smartor is a combination of ultrasonic testing and ultrasonic thickness me
...
asurement. ●IP 66 ●Compact size: 198 (W)* 128 (H) *520 (D) mm ●0.9kg only with battery ●5.7" LCD with high resolution 640×480 pixels ●One-hand operation ●Multiple conventional UT functions ●Smart Test Wizard ●Weld Simulation
>

Exertus Dual 120

The Exertus Dual 120 Projector has the ability to accept Iridium 192 sources or Selenium 75 source
...
s. This projector incorporates design and safety features that make it flexible, compact and lightweight. The Projector is lighter than most of its competitors. It incorporates an improved source channel, based on a new helicoidal design, which makes maintenance easier. The helicoidal design also allows smoother movement of the source assembly inside the device, making it easier for the operator and improving safety. The Projector also has a unique safety feature not found in competitive products. The source assembly locking mechanism is triggered by the source holder capsule at the front of the source assembly, thereby always assuring the operator that the source has returned to the safe position. The Exertus Dual 120 is ISO3999:2004 compliant.
>

Trade-In Offer

We are offering our existing clients trade-in against Wavemaker® G3 systems, Standard (Blue) inflat
...
able rings and modules for excellent deals on the latest Wavemaker® G4mini system.
>

Share...
We use technical and analytics cookies to ensure that we will give you the best experience of our website - More Info
Accept
top
this is debug window