where expertise comes together - since 1996

Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)
Open Access Database (Conference Proceedings, Articles, News), Exhibition, Forum, Network

All Forum Boards
Technical Discussions >
NDE of Plastics
Career Discussions
Job Offers
Job Seeks
Classified Ads
About NDT.net
Articles & News

1102 views
02:27 Dec-03-1999
Niles Stenmark
NDE of Plastics

I am currently a graduate student at UW-Milwaukee. I am working
on the determination of Young's modulus for polyester/particulate
composites from ultrasonic shear and longitudinal velocities. I then take
my samples and determine Young's modulus by compression testing.
My data suggests strongly that Young's modulus determined from
NDE is about double the value obtained from compression testing.
A team and myself have thoroughly checked over the calculations for
error. Is this common in plastics? Is there any explanation for
the data variations?


 
02:23 Dec-04-1999
Chris Edwards
Re: NDE of Plastics : I am currently a graduate student at UW-Milwaukee. I am working
: on the determination of Young's modulus for polyester/particulate
: composites from ultrasonic shear and longitudinal velocities. I then take
: my samples and determine Young's modulus by compression testing.
: My data suggests strongly that Young's modulus determined from
: NDE is about double the value obtained from compression testing.
: A team and myself have thoroughly checked over the calculations for
: error. Is this common in plastics? Is there any explanation for
: the data variations?

Many plastics are viscoelastic ie soft at low stain rates but harder at high stain rates.
Young modulus determined by a compression test is low frequency ie soft.
Whereas Youngs Modulus determined ultrasonically (high frequency)will be higher as the material appears stiffer.


 
05:57 Jan-31-2000

Valliyappan David Natarajan

Student, Research Assistant
National University of Malaysia,
Malaysia,
Joined Jan 2000
4
Re: NDE of Plastics : I am currently a graduate student at UW-Milwaukee. I am working
: on the determination of Young's modulus for polyester/particulate
: composites from ultrasonic shear and longitudinal velocities. I then take
: my samples and determine Young's modulus by compression testing.
: My data suggests strongly that Young's modulus determined from
: NDE is about double the value obtained from compression testing.
: A team and myself have thoroughly checked over the calculations for
: error. Is this common in plastics? Is there any explanation for
: the data variations?

Mr.Niles Stenmark,

I am a graduate from the National University of Malaysia,currently pursuing
my Masters's degree from the same university.
My undergraduate final year project entitled "Characterization of Natural Fibre Reinforced Polymer Composites using
Non-Destructive Ultrasonic Technique" involves determination of the Young Modulus and Shear Modulus
of oil palm frond short fiber reinforced polyester from the ultrasonic longitudinal
velocity and correlating it with the same quantities obtained from conventional tensile test (ASTM D638M).
As your observation too, the results which I got strongly shows this correlation :

NDE value = 2 * TensileTest value [ or a correlation of 100% ].

Thereabout, I suggest that some mathematical modification to be made to the
equations presented by the ASTM D638M standard to enhance the approximation
values given by NDE method so as to validate the NDE method. Maybe the mathematical
equations presented in the ASTM D638M was validated only for metals and not specific
for reinforced polymers.

Please inform me if there is any efforts that you have taken in order to justify
your results (ie. the difference between NDE and compression test methods and results).
Thank you.
email : valli_3@hotmail.com




 
07:20 Jan-31-2000

John A. Brunk

Engineering, NDT Level III
Self employed, part-time,
USA,
Joined Oct 1999
157
Re: NDE of Plastics The mechanical properties of many plastics and composites are strain rate sensitive. There may also be significant differences between properties measured in compression,tension, and shear. Many composites are anisotropic.
2 does seem to be a reasonable correction factor for many materials. When you want to compare the mechanical properties of samples of essentially the same material, it may be sufficient to perform the actual mechanical testing on one of the samples to determine the correlation between this data and ultrasonic velocity.
Some composites exhibit different ultrasonic velocities at different frequencies as well as in different directions. It is much easier and more reliable to compare the impact of some processing variable on the properties of one material than to try to generalize about a group of materials.


 
07:22 Jan-31-2000

John A. Brunk

Engineering, NDT Level III
Self employed, part-time,
USA,
Joined Oct 1999
157
Re: NDE of Plastics The mechanical properties of many plastics and composites are strain rate sensitive. There may also be significant differences between properties measured in compression,tension, and shear. Many composites are anisotropic.
2 does seem to be a reasonable correction factor for many materials. When you want to compare the mechanical properties of samples of essentially the same material, it may be sufficient to perform the actual mechanical testing on one of the samples to determine the correlation between this data and ultrasonic velocity.
Some composites exhibit different ultrasonic velocities at different frequencies as well as in different directions. It is much easier and more reliable to compare the impact of some processing variable on the properties of one material than to try to generalize about a group of materials.


 
09:55 Feb-01-2000
Damir
Re: NDE of Plastics ptly for ASTM and:
http://www.astm.org/cgi-bin/SoftCart.exe/DATABASE.CART/PAGES/D638M.htm?L+mystore+ceqx4960
(Withdrawn 1998)
I suppose nothing at all with standard modification, but I am very curious on
the content of this standard. Could you please send me a copy.

regards,
D.Markucic



 
00:18 Feb-01-2000

Damir Markucic

Teacher, R&D
Faculty of Mechanical Eng., University of Zagreb,
Croatia,
Joined Nov 1998
5
Re: NDE of Plastics


 


© NDT.net - The Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT) ISSN 1435-4934

Open Access Database, |Conference Proceedings| |Articles| |News| |Exhibition| |Forum| |Professional Network|