where expertise comes together - since 1996

Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)
Open Access Database (Conference Proceedings, Articles, News), Exhibition, Forum, Network

All Forum Boards
Technical Discussions >
ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks
Career Discussions
Job Offers
Job Seeks
Classified Ads
About NDT.net
Articles & News

Mammon Technologies LLP
1-Stop Shop for all your NDT Needs. Radiography, GPR, Thermography and acoustic devices. We sell worldwide. We train worldwide. We support worldwide.

2299 views
03:48 Aug-25-2008
Kumar
ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks

Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.

Thks!


 
00:08 Aug-26-2008
mj
Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks Dear Friend, as per code case 2235-09 qualification block shall be prepared by welding or HIP and ahll contain 3 flaws( it maybe a diffect or notch/side drilled hole. the diffrence between both calibration and qualification block is, one made just in a plate and other in a welding, also usualy if u make a small thickness qualificatin block during welding u can keep some welding rod inside and weld. also you can keep a RT report for the block. iam sure flaw maybe a natural defect or artificial!!!! always iam making this kind of blocks
Please let me know others comment. if iam not right please respond.

mj


----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.
: Thks!
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
00:49 Aug-27-2008

mustafa GONULAL

Engineering,
CIMTAS / ENKA,
Turkey,
Joined Jun 2008
8
Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks Dear peers,
I am drawing and producing calibration and qualification blocks over 4 years. If you want to know more detail contact with me via e-mail.

----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Dear Friend, as per code case 2235-09 qualification block shall be prepared by welding or HIP and ahll contain 3 flaws( it maybe a diffect or notch/side drilled hole. the diffrence between both calibration and qualification block is, one made just in a plate and other in a welding, also usualy if u make a small thickness qualificatin block during welding u can keep some welding rod inside and weld. also you can keep a RT report for the block. iam sure flaw maybe a natural defect or artificial!!!! always iam making this kind of blocks
: Please let me know others comment. if iam not right please respond.
: mj
:
: : Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.
: : Thks!
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
02:44 Aug-28-2008

Michael Moles †2014 *1948

,
Joined

Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Dear peers,
: I am drawing and producing calibration and qualification blocks over 4 years. If you want to know more detail contact with me via e-mail.
: : Dear Friend, as per code case 2235-09 qualification block shall be prepared by welding or HIP and ahll contain 3 flaws( it maybe a diffect or notch/side drilled hole. the diffrence between both calibration and qualification block is, one made just in a plate and other in a welding, also usualy if u make a small thickness qualificatin block during welding u can keep some welding rod inside and weld. also you can keep a RT report for the block. iam sure flaw maybe a natural defect or artificial!!!! always iam making this kind of blocks
: : Please let me know others comment. if iam not right please respond.
: : mj
: :
: : : Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.
: : : Thks!
------------ End Original Message ------------

Unfortunately, you are not correct in your interpretation. While the original ASME CC 2235 was not clear on this issue, the intent was to use artificial cracks - not side drilled holes or notches - as the reflectors. In addition, the artificial cracks should follow the bevel to simulate Lack of Fusion defects or similar. ASME is currently working on clarifying this situation.

Michael Moles
Member, ASME Section V Ultrasonics Working Group



 
09:04 Aug-30-2008
mj
Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : Dear peers,
: : I am drawing and producing calibration and qualification blocks over 4 years. If you want to know more detail contact with me via e-mail.
: : : Dear Friend, as per code case 2235-09 qualification block shall be prepared by welding or HIP and ahll contain 3 flaws( it maybe a diffect or notch/side drilled hole. the diffrence between both calibration and qualification block is, one made just in a plate and other in a welding, also usualy if u make a small thickness qualificatin block during welding u can keep some welding rod inside and weld. also you can keep a RT report for the block. iam sure flaw maybe a natural defect or artificial!!!! always iam making this kind of blocks
: : : Please let me know others comment. if iam not right please respond.
: : : mj
: : :
: : : : Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.
: : : : Thks!
: Unfortunately, you are not correct in your interpretation. While the original ASME CC 2235 was not clear on this issue, the intent was to use artificial cracks - not side drilled holes or notches - as the reflectors. In addition, the artificial cracks should follow the bevel to simulate Lack of Fusion defects or similar. ASME is currently working on clarifying this situation.
: Michael Moles
: Member, ASME Section V Ultrasonics Working Group
------------ End Original Message ------------

Thanks Michael we are only using code case 2235-09 or asme sec.V for the inspection . sure i did atleast 25 project using the same code and with a normal demo block. if something diffrent come out from ASME we will follow it
MJ


 
00:09 Sep-10-2008
EC
Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : : Dear peers,
: : : I am drawing and producing calibration and qualification blocks over 4 years. If you want to know more detail contact with me via e-mail.
: : : : Dear Friend, as per code case 2235-09 qualification block shall be prepared by welding or HIP and ahll contain 3 flaws( it maybe a diffect or notch/side drilled hole. the diffrence between both calibration and qualification block is, one made just in a plate and other in a welding, also usualy if u make a small thickness qualificatin block during welding u can keep some welding rod inside and weld. also you can keep a RT report for the block. iam sure flaw maybe a natural defect or artificial!!!! always iam making this kind of blocks
: : : : Please let me know others comment. if iam not right please respond.
: : : : mj
: : : :
: : : : : Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.
: : : : : Thks!
: : Unfortunately, you are not correct in your interpretation. While the original ASME CC 2235 was not clear on this issue, the intent was to use artificial cracks - not side drilled holes or notches - as the reflectors. In addition, the artificial cracks should follow the bevel to simulate Lack of Fusion defects or similar. ASME is currently working on clarifying this situation.
: : Michael Moles
: : Member, ASME Section V Ultrasonics Working Group
: Thanks Michael we are only using code case 2235-09 or asme sec.V for the inspection . sure i did atleast 25 project using the same code and with a normal demo block. if something diffrent come out from ASME we will follow it
: MJ
------------ End Original Message ------------

Hello, we are working with TOFD inspection procedures following ASME V and VIII and we've a problem with the interpretation of the qualification block's thickness. Could somebody explain us what thickness we must choose for a range of inspection of 25 to 200 mm?
thanks!!!!


 
01:17 Sep-10-2008

Nigel Armstrong

Engineering, - Specialist services
United Kingdom,
Joined Oct 2000
1094
Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks Hi EC

You should read the 2007 Edition of ASME V, Article 4 Mandatory Appendix III, TOFD of welds. Calibration block thickness and range qualified are clearly stated in III-434.

Regards

Nigel

----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : : : Dear peers,
: : : : I am drawing and producing calibration and qualification blocks over 4 years. If you want to know more detail contact with me via e-mail.
: : : : : Dear Friend, as per code case 2235-09 qualification block shall be prepared by welding or HIP and ahll contain 3 flaws( it maybe a diffect or notch/side drilled hole. the diffrence between both calibration and qualification block is, one made just in a plate and other in a welding, also usualy if u make a small thickness qualificatin block during welding u can keep some welding rod inside and weld. also you can keep a RT report for the block. iam sure flaw maybe a natural defect or artificial!!!! always iam making this kind of blocks
: : : : : Please let me know others comment. if iam not right please respond.
: : : : : mj
: : : : :
: : : : : : Could anyone tell me where can I have the UT qualification/demonstration blocks made to ASME Code case 2235? The flaws are supposed to be actual flaws generated by welding.
: : : : : : Thks!
: : : Unfortunately, you are not correct in your interpretation. While the original ASME CC 2235 was not clear on this issue, the intent was to use artificial cracks - not side drilled holes or notches - as the reflectors. In addition, the artificial cracks should follow the bevel to simulate Lack of Fusion defects or similar. ASME is currently working on clarifying this situation.
: : : Michael Moles
: : : Member, ASME Section V Ultrasonics Working Group
: : Thanks Michael we are only using code case 2235-09 or asme sec.V for the inspection . sure i did atleast 25 project using the same code and with a normal demo block. if something diffrent come out from ASME we will follow it
: : MJ
: Hello, we are working with TOFD inspection procedures following ASME V and VIII and we've a problem with the interpretation of the qualification block's thickness. Could somebody explain us what thickness we must choose for a range of inspection of 25 to 200 mm?
: thanks!!!!
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
08:54 Dec-12-2008

David Mackintosh

Engineering,
Acuren Group Inc.,
Canada,
Joined Feb 2011
85
Re: ASME Code Case 2235 Qualification blocks ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Hi EC
: You should read the 2007 Edition of ASME V, Article 4 Mandatory Appendix III, TOFD of welds. Calibration block thickness and range qualified are clearly stated in III-434.
: Regards
: Nigel
-------------------------------------------------

I believe that Appendix III only specifies the CALIBRATION block. For the QUALIFICATION block, Code Case 2235 only requires the three flaws and says very little about the block design. It is up to the Owner to design a qualification/demonstration block specific to their needs.

David


 


© NDT.net - The Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT) ISSN 1435-4934

Open Access Database, |Conference Proceedings| |Articles| |News| |Exhibition| |Forum| |Professional Network|