where expertise comes together - since 1996 -

The Largest Open Access Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)

Conference Proceedings, Articles, News, Exhibition, Forum, Network and more

where expertise comes together
- since 1996 -
Mobile-Friendly Implementation in Progress

2873 views
Career Discussions
NELSON
Engineering, QAQC MECHANICAL ENGINEER
HYUNDAI ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION CO.LTD, Philippines, Joined Feb 2008, 3

NELSON

Engineering, QAQC MECHANICAL ENGINEER
HYUNDAI ENGINEERING & CONSTRUCTION CO.LTD,
Philippines,
Joined Feb 2008
3
04:31 May-23-2008
aws and api standard for ut acceptance criterion

could you please tell me the difference of AWS and API STANDARD for ultrasonic testing acceptance criteria for flaws on weld?i.e.,porosity,slags,etc.


    
 
 
Luis Santoyo
Luis Santoyo
01:59 May-23-2008
Re: aws and api standard for ut acceptance criterion
The main difference is that AWS apply to structural welds and API like API 1104 to welds in pipes of Oil Industry, also, with API you probably need to use DAC to evaluate discontinuities, with AWS D1.1, you make some calculations regarding to the amplitude of the discontinuity against a known amplitude (Some new equipments already have it) and you are able to say if the indication is accepted or rejected. With AWS you may only use wedges of 45 -60 and 70 degrees.
Hope this can help you
----------- Start Original Message -----------
: could you please tell me the difference of AWS and API STANDARD for ultrasonic testing acceptance criteria for flaws on weld?i.e.,porosity,slags,etc.
------------ End Original Message ------------




    
 
 
Gowri Santhosh
NDT Inspector,
Royscan engineering pte ltd, Singapore, Joined May 2008, 51

Gowri Santhosh

NDT Inspector,
Royscan engineering pte ltd,
Singapore,
Joined May 2008
51
04:46 May-24-2008
Re: aws and api standard for ut acceptance criterion
----------- Start Original Message -----------
: The main difference is that AWS apply to structural welds and API like API 1104 to welds in pipes of Oil Industry, also, with API you probably need to use DAC to evaluate discontinuities, with AWS D1.1, you make some calculations regarding to the amplitude of the discontinuity against a known amplitude (Some new equipments already have it) and you are able to say if the indication is accepted or rejected. With AWS you may only use wedges of 45 -60 and 70 degrees.
: Hope this can help you
: : could you please tell me the difference of AWS and API STANDARD for ultrasonic testing acceptance criteria for flaws on weld?i.e.,porosity,slags,etc.
------------ End Original Message ------------

Hi,
This is Gowri from india. Go to matter.
First of all API acceptance criteria is very simple and not confident. If any echo amplitude exceeding 100% of DAC, you have to give x-ray prove up for Additonal verification. Here the radiography is the final testing to the discontinuity Evaluation. You cant reject or repair the weld with UT.
In AWS, acceptance criteria is effective and critical(in early days). Here we have to consider lot of things such as reference dB, flaw indication dB, attenuation factor and indication rating. A table (6.2 & 6.3) is provided in AWS D1.1 for acceptance criteria. You can get lot of information there. Now all UFD are having AWS mode for easy evaluation.


    
 
 
Gowri santhosh
NDT Inspector,
Royscan engineering pte ltd, Singapore, Joined May 2008, 51

Gowri santhosh

NDT Inspector,
Royscan engineering pte ltd,
Singapore,
Joined May 2008
51
06:51 May-24-2008
Re: aws and api standard for ut acceptance criterion
Hi,
The two main differences are there. In API, reference standards or blocks are used for calibration as well as in AWS standard blocks (IIW V1) are used. And there is no necessity to make DAC in AWS A.C,. DAC is used for evaluation in API a.c,. (a.c- acceptance criteria)


    
 
 
SHAI
Consultant, octg inspector
services, United Arab Emirates (UAE), Joined May 2007, 1

SHAI

Consultant, octg inspector
services,
United Arab Emirates (UAE),
Joined May 2007
1
00:41 May-24-2008
Re: aws and api standard for ut acceptance criterion
----------- Start Original Message -----------
: could you please tell me the difference of AWS and API STANDARD for ultrasonic testing acceptance criteria for flaws on weld?i.e.,porosity,slags,etc.
------------ End Original Message ------------

Dear nelson

AWS is for stractural component. like building offshore, and API is for drilling tools and pipeline.

On Fri, May 23, 2008 at 5:06 PM, wrote:





    
 
 

NDTkit RT
NDTkit RT, TESTIA's Digital Radiography software The NDTkit product line software for X-ray
TESTIA
5 Showcases 2 Videos Product Video

Cygnus 6+ PRO Multi-Mode Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge
The Cygnus 6+ PRO thickness gauge is the most advance gauge within the Cygnus range with key
Cygnus Instruments Ltd
5 Showcases 5 Videos Product Video

Immersion systems
ScanMaster ultrasonic immersion systems are designed for high throughput, multi shift operation in
ScanMaster Systems (IRT) Ltd.
5 Showcases 5 Videos Product Video

Lyft™: Pulsed Eddy Current Reinvented
PEC Reinvented—CUI Programs Redefined Corrosion under insulation (CUI) is possibly the greatest
Eddyfi
4 Showcases 5 Videos Product Video

More Showcases

Share...
We use technical and analytics cookies to ensure that we will give you the best experience of our website - More Info
Accept
top
this is debug window