where expertise comes together - since 1996

Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)
Open Access Database (Conference Proceedings, Articles, News), Exhibition, Forum, Network

All Forum Boards
Technical Discussions >
Notification of New Forum Members
Career Discussions
Job Offers
Job Seeks
Classified Ads
About NDT.net
Articles & News

Sonotron NDT
Original developer and manufacturer of advanced ultrasonic instruments

5148 views
01:15 Mar-22-2001

Rolf Diederichs

Director, Editor, Publisher, Internet, PHP MySQL
NDT.net,
Germany,
Joined Nov 1998
599
Notification of New Forum Members

Dear Forum Member,

A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
What is your opinion?

Best regards
Rolf Diederichs


 
01:29 Mar-22-2001

William Blum

Consultant, Training, Level III Services
NDT Consulting Group Inc.,
USA,
Joined Nov 2000
89
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.

Personally I like to hear about the new members.



 
01:46 Mar-22-2001

Wolfgang Bisle

R & D, Project leader & Group Leader InService Inspect.
Airbus Deutschland GmbH,
Germany,
Joined Jul 2000
35
Re: Notification of New Forum Members What should it be good for. In the last days my mailbox was spammed with lots of notifications of the ndt.net which immediately went into trash. For what must I know about who has just decided to join the forum. If I am interested to see who is member I can do it by looking for the appropriate link in ndt.net.
But such automatic mail disturbs my normal mail traffic which is already really huge.
For me this service is spam.


 
02:40 Mar-22-2001

Macelo Pinheiro Mendes

Student
Rio de Janeiro Federal University,
Brazil,
Joined Feb 2001
3
Re: Notification of New Forum Members I personally exchanged information because of new member announcement. But I agree that for members who receive mails all day as institution/company directors it is necessary to filter mail. However, I do not consider new member notification as spam

: What should it be good for. In the last days my mailbox was spammed with lots of notifications of the ndt.net which immediately went into trash. For what must I know about who has just decided to join the forum. If I am interested to see who is member I can do it by looking for the appropriate link in ndt.net.
: But such automatic mail disturbs my normal mail traffic which is already really huge.
: For me this service is spam.
.



 
02:52 Mar-22-2001

Philippe Rubbers

Engineering
SCM,
South Africa,
Joined Nov 1998
21
Re: Notification of New Forum Members A single e-mail once a month indicating the new members should be sufficient for most users.
An e-mail for each new user is excessive.


 
03:51 Mar-22-2001

Dent McIntyre

Consultant, NDE Manager NDELevel III/3
NDT Consultant,
Canada,
Joined Nov 1998
243
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs

This service is NOT value added. Please discontinue it.

Dent McIntyre


 
04:08 Mar-22-2001

Ishbel Macdonald

Consultant, Engineering Consultant - NDT
Subsea 7,
Norway,
Joined Nov 1998
11
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.
Rolf

I would have to agree with Dent McIntyre's conmment - it does not add value, and is information that can easily be found by looking into the list of new members

Regards
Ishbel Macdonald
NDT Specialist
DNV



 
04:36 Mar-22-2001

Randy Plis

Sales, Consultant
AMDATA NDE Technology LLC,
USA,
Joined Oct 1999
23
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : : Dear Forum Member,
: .
: : A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: : I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: : and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: : I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: : What is your opinion?
: .
: : Best regards
: : Rolf Diederichs
: .
: Rolf
.
: Both opinions are valid. Being aware of new members is welcomed information, and increasing e-mail traffic is becoming a problem. Rolf, as a compromise solution, would it be possible to combine notices of new members into a single e-mail each week, or when a total of 10 occurs, whichever occurs first? Thanks.

Cheers,
Randy Plis
Westinghouse AMDATA
Windsor, CT USA


 
04:41 Mar-22-2001
Joseph Pascente
Notification of New Forum Members Rolf,

I agree with Randy in having one Email for a weeks
list of for every 10 new members.


Regards,

Joe Pascente


 
04:51 Mar-22-2001
Ishbel Macdonald
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : Rolf,
.
: I agree with Randy in having one Email for a weeks
: list of for every 10 new members.
.
:
: Regards,
.
: Joe Pascente
.

Joe
This is already available on the NDTnet forum page. It lists the new members for the previous 30 days. At least that way, folk that are not so interested don't have to keep receiving "unwanted" e-mails, but the information is there for those who do.
Regards
Ishbel Macdonald


 
05:24 Mar-22-2001

Ulrich Mletzko

R & D, Retired
Germany,
Joined Nov 1998
89
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : A single e-mail once a month indicating the new
members should be sufficient for most users.

This seems to be a good compromise.

Regards
Uli Mletzko, MPA-S / NDT



 
05:39 Mar-22-2001

Tim MacInnis

Senior NDT Engineer
SAIC/Ultra Iamge International,
USA,
Joined Dec 1999
10
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.
Rolf,
The questions and answers are most enjoyable and informative. Based on the traffic this post has generated I will go with the crowd, once a month new member postings would be adequate.
Tim MacInnis



 
05:55 Mar-22-2001
John Klenzing
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.

It is initially a good thought ... however upon receiving several days of new members it is cumbersome and should at least be an optional feature.


 
05:58 Mar-22-2001
John Klenzing
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : What should it be good for. In the last days my mailbox was spammed with lots of notifications of the ndt.net which immediately went into trash. For what must I know about who has just decided to join the forum. If I am interested to see who is member I can do it by looking for the appropriate link in ndt.net.
: But such automatic mail disturbs my normal mail traffic which is already really huge.
: For me this service is spam.
.

>>>>>>>>I am in agreement with this point of view.




 
06:00 Mar-22-2001
Sophia Puskas
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Rolf, I enjoy learning of new forum members. It is nice to see who is joining the forum and from which part of the world they are lending their comments, suggestions and expertise. I am sometimes surprised to see an old colleague's name with whom I haven't had contact for a while! It helps me to remember them again and it also helps to update any old coordinate information I may not have changed. I like the service and I thank you for it. For the cynics who insist that this service is not useful, I do believe that they can use their "delete" button and allow the rest of us to benefit from the notification.


 
06:15 Mar-22-2001
jonathan kaufman
Re: Notification of New Forum Members personally, i don't want to get any announcements of
new members. put it on the web site: "New Members"
and be done with it. In fact i am sure that no one
even wants to get any emails discussing this anymore!

thanks.


: : : Dear Forum Member,
: : .
: : : A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: : : I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: : : and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: : : I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: : : What is your opinion?
: : .
: : : Best regards
: : : Rolf Diederichs
: : .
: : Rolf
: .
: : Both opinions are valid. Being aware of new members is welcomed information, and increasing e-mail traffic is becoming a problem. Rolf, as a compromise solution, would it be possible to combine notices of new members into a single e-mail each week, or when a total of 10 occurs, whichever occurs first? Thanks.
.
: Cheers,
: Randy Plis
: Westinghouse AMDATA
: Windsor, CT USA
.



 
06:21 Mar-22-2001
Liviu Singher
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Hello Rolf,

I also intended to write to you that this is not critical information.
Anyone can look at the members at his own free time and it quite
bothers to receive it through messages.

Best regards,
Liviu Singher

: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
06:22 Mar-22-2001

Mirek Macecek

R & D,
Techno Scientific Inc,
Canada,
Joined Nov 1998
6
Re: Notification of New Forum Members MacecekTSI@aol.com

I agree with the last member, a summary once a month would be fine
.Mirek Macecek


: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
06:23 Mar-22-2001

Fred Raco

Director
CP Industries - Div. of Reunion Industries, Inc.,
USA,
Joined Jan 2001
6
Re: Notification of New Forum Members : A single e-mail once a month indicating the new members should be sufficient for most users.
: An e-mail for each new user is excessive.


I agree!



 
06:24 Mar-22-2001
Lesley Rawding
Re: Notification of New Forum Members
Nice to know who is joining, may be somebody we know from the past. It's no
trouble to delete without reading if not interested.
Regards
Gary


: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
06:25 Mar-22-2001

Godfrey Hands

Engineering,
PRI Nadcap,
United Kingdom,
Joined Nov 1998
281
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Rolf,
I personally would prefer not to see these messages.
Perhaps once per month (or every two weeks) a message giving name and
country of new members, and we can then look at membership list if we
want to.


: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
06:26 Mar-22-2001

cak nair

Consultant
COOPERHEAT,
Kuwait,
Joined Jan 2001
1
Re: Notification of New Forum Members yes,I agree not required.

: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
06:27 Mar-22-2001

Rich Roberts

Engineering, Executive Managment
Quest Integrity Group,
USA,
Joined Nov 1998
78
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Rolf,

I welcome the notification of new members. This allows me to know who the
other experts are who are available.

Regards,
Rich Roberts

: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
06:27 Mar-22-2001

SEB

Sales
OIS Engineering Ltd,
United Kingdom,
Joined Feb 2000
5
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Dear Rolf,

Please come to your conclusion quickly. The number of sign-up notifications being received will soon pale into insignificance compared to the amount of correspondence generated during this debate.


 
06:28 Mar-22-2001

McIntyre, J. D.

Consultant, NDE Manager NDELevel III/3
NDT Consultant,
Canada,
Joined Nov 1998
243
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Rolf:

All of the activity regarding this topic is taking away from the technical
good that your forum does.

My suggestion is to stop all this activity immediately and if you wish send
it once a month.

Dent McIntyre
NDE Manager
B & W Canada

: Dear Forum Member,
.
: A new forum feature notifies via email when new forum members signed up.
: I have received a couple of complains that this new feature may not be necessary
: and overlades the number of messages that are being received.
: I personally thought that it would be a welcome information.
: What is your opinion?
.
: Best regards
: Rolf Diederichs
.



 
03:35 Mar-22-2001

John Pursley

R & D
Envision Product Design,
USA,
Joined Oct 1999
23
Re: Notification of New Forum Members A single e-mail listing 10 new members would suffice.



 
09:15 Mar-23-2001

Ishbel Macdonald

Consultant, Engineering Consultant - NDT
Subsea 7,
Norway,
Joined Nov 1998
11
Re: Notification of New Forum Members Yes, it is easy to delete, however, our mail server is already stretched enough without this type of doubling of information. The new members link on the NDTnet Forum page is more than sufficient.

Ishbel


 


© NDT.net - The Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT) ISSN 1435-4934

Open Access Database, |Conference Proceedings| |Articles| |News| |Exhibition| |Forum| |Professional Network|