where expertise comes together - since 1996 -

The Largest Open Access Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)

Conference Proceedings, Articles, News, Exhibition, Forum, Network and more

where expertise comes together
- since 1996 -
Mobile-Friendly Implementation in Progress

IMechE Engineering Training Solutions
World leading provider of Non-Destructive Testing and Corrosion Prevention and Coatings training, examinations and Level 3 Consultancy Services

2587 views
Technical Discussions
ovidiu iuga
NDT Inspector, thermography
ISCIR, Romania, Joined Dec 2005, 16

ovidiu iuga

NDT Inspector, thermography
ISCIR,
Romania,
Joined Dec 2005
16
07:36 Jul-01-2009
UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius

Does anybody performed succefully UT of welded seams (pipes) at high temperature (200 deg. Celsius and above)? Any special requirments? Any specs for this kind of UT.

Regards,
Ovidiu IUGA

    
 
 
Roger Duwe
NDT Inspector, API-510, 570, 653
MISTRAS, USA, Joined Jan 2009, 148

Roger Duwe

NDT Inspector, API-510, 570, 653
MISTRAS,
USA,
Joined Jan 2009
148
20:52 Jul-01-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to ovidiu iuga at 07:36 Jul-01-2009 (Opening).

200 deg C is marginal. In addition to high-temp couplant [I prefer silicone 'vacuum' grease] and preheating both calibration blocks -- IIW and DAC curve standards to closly match the actual weld temp, you will have to 'baby' your transducer and wedge. The wedge will need to be hi-temp material [phenolic or similar], but the transducer can be a standard 'ducer IF you cool the wedge in water every minute or so [without shorting out the 'ducer]. Additionally, the UT operator will be rather slow, due to the danger of severe burns and the difficulty of properly manipulating the 'ducer with heavy gloves on.

Do not take any shortcuts on calibration, including the refracted angle. There is a large change in metal velocity going from 25 to 200 degrees, the attenuation rate changes, etc.

    
 
 
Michel Couture
NDT Inspector,
consultant, Canada, Joined Sep 2006, 819

Michel Couture

NDT Inspector,
consultant,
Canada,
Joined Sep 2006
819
21:05 Jul-01-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to Roger Duwe at 20:52 Jul-01-2009 .

I've read a few of these queries regarding High Temp UT and I find it strange that no one has questionned the possiblility of Cold Cracking? I was told about this when I started doing weld inspection, so I wonder why one would do weld inspection at 200 ºC., let alone the possiblility of burning oneself...

    
 
 
Tom Nelligan
Engineering,
retired, USA, Joined Nov 1998, 390

Tom Nelligan

Engineering,
retired,
USA,
Joined Nov 1998
390
21:28 Jul-01-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to ovidiu iuga at 07:36 Jul-01-2009 (Opening).

You should also keep in mind that even when using a high temperature wedge, the refracted beam angle will change as the wedge temperature changes, due to the changes in wedge velocity. As a practical matter, this can be very difficult to reliably track. You may wish to read our application note on high temperature ultrasonic testing for further discussion


http://www.olympus-ims.com/en/ndt-application/183-id.209715235.html

    
 
 
S.V.Swamy
Engineering, - Material Testing Inspection & Quality Control
Retired from Nuclear Fuel Complex , India, Joined Feb 2001, 785

S.V.Swamy

Engineering, - Material Testing Inspection & Quality Control
Retired from Nuclear Fuel Complex ,
India,
Joined Feb 2001
785
07:25 Jul-02-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to ovidiu iuga at 07:36 Jul-01-2009 (Opening).

I know you are getting very good technical replies. However, I get one basic doubt, which you can also think over and of course, the other NDT experts are also welcome to share their wisdom.

Is it really necessary for the UT to be done at 200 C? From the question I get a feeling that you are talking of a pipeline in a factory used to carry some fluids and or steam / some other gases. Can't there be a shut down in such a case and the UT performed during the shut down when the pipe will be at the ambient temperature?

Also, a hot pipe would normally be insulated to keep the energy losses low. Have you considered the need for removing the insulation before test and reinstalling the insulation after the test? And have the plant operators considered the thermal losses when the insulation is removed for the duration of the test?

RT may be a better option if the pipe welds indeed need to be tested at the high temperature and you could in theory do it without removing the thermal insulation!

Trying to answer such questions will be helpful not only for the NDT inspectors but to the management in general.

My best regards to you and the Forum.

Swamy

    
 
 
peter
peter
10:14 Jul-02-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to S.V.Swamy at 07:25 Jul-02-2009 .

Swamy
You are right practically the line is insulated,and RT would be beneficial,but from a operating(nucleonics/tripping) point of view RT cannot be used in some operating conditions especially in the upstream oil industry,and the planned shutdown may be months away,hence knowing the conditon of the existing welds becoms a priority especially when we have a inservice weld failure,eg which is attributed to weld root corrosion.Knowing the existing condition of the remaining welds becomes a priority so that we could migitate the risk
In this instance i would strip the insulation from the welds and inspect them by UT,though some govt legislations donot allow this from a operator safety point of view,but practically you could.

    
 
 
Mark Nel
Sales, Application support
Technology Design Ltd., United Kingdom, Joined Jul 2005, 58

Mark Nel

Sales, Application support
Technology Design Ltd.,
United Kingdom,
Joined Jul 2005
58
11:07 Jul-02-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to peter at 10:14 Jul-02-2009 .

There is an old technique for root erosion/corrosion validation using ToFD viewed on an unrectified A-Scan display and using simple purpose-made reference blocks that was or perhaps still still is widely used in the North Sea. This technique is very fast therefore minimising contact time with the hot surface to no more than a minute or two. Perhaps some of our older members with experience of this technique may shed some light as to whether it could be used for Ovidiu's application effectively.

    
 
 
Luis Ganhao
Engineering,
USA, Joined Sep 2008, 25

Luis Ganhao

Engineering,
USA,
Joined Sep 2008
25
17:03 Jul-02-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to ovidiu iuga at 07:36 Jul-01-2009 (Opening).

Please try with EMAT (elctromaganetic trasnducers UT) I think this technique is one of the more used in this case, there is some companies that perform a lot of inspections at high temp. with EMAT one of them is MATRIX and IRISNDT

    
 
 
Syed Ali
Syed Ali
22:07 Jul-03-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to ovidiu iuga at 07:36 Jul-01-2009 (Opening).

EMATs can be used easily to inspect welded seams at high temperature (>200 C). I am not sure what is the thickness range of the pipes. If guided waves are possible EMAT would be a great solution. We have done high temperature applications with EMAT ( 650 C and above) for thickness measurements and probes are presently working in line at plants in USA.
Please refer to www.innerspec.com for further information.

Regards
Syed Ali

    
 
 
Abbas Bombaywala
NDT Inspector
Free Lance, India, Joined Jul 2007, 91

Abbas Bombaywala

NDT Inspector
Free Lance,
India,
Joined Jul 2007
91
22:08 Jul-06-2009
Re: UT welded seams at 200 deg. celsius
In Reply to ovidiu iuga at 07:36 Jul-01-2009 (Opening).

Well high temprature increase too many parameters to be kept in mind for Ultrasonic Testing, Your Cal Block need preheating upto the temprature of material to be inspected, The wedge temprature to be maintained by cooling the wedge after certain time. Change in wedge temprature will give u change in your angle. EMAT Probes is a good option as advised by other NDT Technician,

But i agree with the points of Mr Swamy, Cause u cant be reliable for high temprature inspections as practicaly there are too many difficulties to inspect a weld above 100 degree temprature, more over there is a chance of Operator getting burnt. So better to do a radiography. Other NDT Specialist might have other views, There are too many NDT Companies doing a high temprature UT & Corrosion Mapping including our company "SGS"

Regards.
Abbas Bombaywala

    
 
 

Research and Applications Development For NDT
The Research and Applications Development (RAD) group is a newly formed team within Acuren
ECLIPSE SCIENTIFIC
3 Showcases 5 Videos

Alpha Pro Digital Radiography System
The Alpha Pro digital X-ray system is the ideal system for your NDT \r\nneeds, as it offers
Vidisco Ltd.
3 Showcases

35 years of VOGT Ultrasonics!
This year we are celebrating a company anniversary! 35 years have passed since we first took our
VOGT Ultrasonics GmbH
3 Showcases Product Video

ISONIC 3510
Very Powerful Superior Performance Extremely Portable Smart Phased Array Ultrasonic Flaw Detector
Sonotron NDT
5 Showcases 5 Videos

More Showcases

Share...

We use technical and analytics cookies to ensure that we will give you the best experience of our website - More Info
Accept
top
this is debug window