where expertise comes together - since 1996 -

The Largest Open Access Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)

Conference Proceedings, Articles, News, Exhibition, Forum, Network and more

where expertise comes together
- since 1996 -

20386 views
Career Discussions
NannaK
Engineering, - QA & QC (Welding/Painting/NDT)
NIS, India, Joined Oct 2008, 2

NannaK

Engineering, - QA & QC (Welding/Painting/NDT)
NIS,
India,
Joined Oct 2008
2
09:06 Jan-01-2010
Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work

Need assistance to this query.
Due to the unavailability of proper qualified welder in site, shall we use the Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work?
Note: (Qualified based on Sec IX) WQR is fulfilling the requirements (essential & supplementary variables) of WPS (AWS D1.1) including impact requirements.

If “YES”, kindly point out the code & clause.
If “NO”, why-(the reason) and where it is mentioned.

 
 Reply 
 
ezio
Other, Retired ex Laboratory Technical Manager
OMECO Research Centre, Italy, Joined Sep 2008, 276

ezio

Other, Retired ex Laboratory Technical Manager
OMECO Research Centre,
Italy,
Joined Sep 2008
276
10:08 Jan-01-2010
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to NannaK at 09:06 Jan-01-2010 (Opening).

I don't thing in the codes you can find the answer. Your proposal is acceptable, but you must obtain the approval of your customer.

 
 Reply 
 
member
NDT Inspector
Shaw Group, USA, Joined Jan 2004, 3

member

NDT Inspector
Shaw Group,
USA,
Joined Jan 2004
3
10:43 Jan-01-2010
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to NannaK at 09:06 Jan-01-2010 (Opening).

ASME Section IX and AWS D1.1 are different code standards.

While there are similarities, a welder is certified by the manufacturer (ASME Does not certify welders - Read QW-300) and a welder qualified per ASME IX rules still will not meet all the criteria of AWS D1.1 and vice versus.

However, there is a path forward and that is to review AWS D1.1 and determine if the welder meets all the AWS D1.1 welder performance essential variables, including test variables and if so, then certify the welder per AWS D1.1 (The manufacturer also does this certification - it does not take a AWS CWI to do so).

 
 Reply 
 
Len Andersen
Engineering
New York City Department of Transportation, USA, Joined Nov 2009, 31

Len Andersen

Engineering
New York City Department of Transportation,
USA,
Joined Nov 2009
31
20:15 Jan-04-2010
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to NannaK at 09:06 Jan-01-2010 (Opening).

Sir,
Read your contract! At the far end it might be read to you in court.
Sincerely
Len Andersen
212-839-6599, 4042 FAX / 914-237-7689 (H) / 914-536-7101 (Mobil)

http://lenandersen.com/personal_info/resume.html

 
 Reply 
 
shelton
shelton
11:41 Aug-23-2011
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to NannaK at 09:06 Jan-01-2010 (Opening).

Yes

You can use an ASME IX welder for AWS D1.1 work provided you meet the essential variable requirements of AWS. This however needs the approval of your client's engineer as defined in the AWS D1.1 code. your reference for this is clause 4.2.2.1 in the 2010 edition.

Regards

 
 Reply 
 
Rachid Belarbi
Consultant, Welding Engineer/NDT Specialist
UNION CARBIDE, USA, Joined Sep 2005, 12

Rachid Belarbi

Consultant, Welding Engineer/NDT Specialist
UNION CARBIDE,
USA,
Joined Sep 2005
12
19:18 Aug-23-2011
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to shelton at 11:41 Aug-23-2011 .

ASME IX is code used for pressure vessel (internal pressure > or = 125 ksi), D1.1 is a code used for structure having no pressure whatsoever but strength applied to them. Any WPQ is based on a WPS, and since the WPS is based on PQR following either codes one would think that it is just impossible to jump from one code to the other.
Nertheless, as one of the expert on this forum pointed out, as long as the essential parameter and supplementary parameters are respected and the changes are approved by the costumer , the shift is parametricaly possible.

 
 Reply 
 
Rachid Belarbi
Consultant, Welding Engineer/NDT Specialist
UNION CARBIDE, USA, Joined Sep 2005, 12

Rachid Belarbi

Consultant, Welding Engineer/NDT Specialist
UNION CARBIDE,
USA,
Joined Sep 2005
12
20:33 Aug-23-2011
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to Rachid Belarbi at 19:18 Aug-23-2011 .

reviewing the set of test for qualifying welder in ASME IX is quite different from the welder qualification on D1.1 (Thickness range, metal deposit allowed, thickness of bend test, reinforcement criteria, visiual criteria to qualifiy the WPQ).
Finally , no , it is not possible to use a welder qualified on ASME IX to perform structural job on AWS D1.1

 
 Reply 
 
Robert P.
Robert P.
16:27 Sep-19-2011
Re: Sec IX qualified welder in AWS D1.1 construction work
In Reply to NannaK at 09:06 Jan-01-2010 (Opening).

You must get Engineer of Record (EOR) written approval of Sec IX welder's WPQ to be able to use welder on AWS D1.1 work.

 
 Reply 
 

Product Spotlight

HARDNESS TESTER TKM-459CE combi

TKM-459CE combi applies 2 methods of hardness control: UCI and Leeb. It provides high-accuracy tes
...
ting of metals and alloys as well as items of different sizes and configurations, their hardened layers and galvanic coatings. Device represents results in HB, HRC, HV and others. Shock-, dust- and water-proof housing with intuitive software make this gauge easy to use in all working conditions.
>

Varex Imaging Large Field of View (FOV) Digital Detector Arrays (DDAs)

A larger FOV DDA can reduce the space and volume of the X-ray inspection system on the factory floor
...
, enable faster scanning times, better throughput and better resolution images at a lower dose. Customers can also save time and money. With these benefits in mind, Varex Imaging has designed a family of large FOV detectors (4343HE, XRD 1611, 4343DX-I, 4343CT) for our industrial imaging customers.
>

NOVO Armor 15 & NOVO Armor 22

The Armor Kit Contains the NOVO Armor, which provides additional mechanical protection to the NOVO 1
...
5WN & NOVO 22WN Detectors, the Armor Stand and a traveling soft cover. - Newest shock absorbent technology case - Water resistant design - Supports wired & wireless communication - Multiple positioning options - Tripod connection using the Built-in 1/4” threads - Simple Detector battery replacement
>

NDT.net launches mobile-friendly design

NDT.net has revamped its website providing a mobile-friendly design.The front page received a comp
...
letely new design and all other sections are now reacting responsively on mobile devices. This has been a major step to make our website more user- friendly.
>

Share...
We use technical and analytics cookies to ensure that we will give you the best experience of our website - More Info
Accept
top
this is debug window