where expertise comes together - since 1996 -

The Largest Open Access Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)

Conference Proceedings, Articles, News, Exhibition, Forum, Network and more

where expertise comes together
- since 1996 -

932 views
Technical Discussions
Carlos
R & D, - -
UCV & EGROUP, Venezuela, Joined Oct 2008, 120

Carlos

R & D, - -
UCV & EGROUP,
Venezuela,
Joined Oct 2008
120
04:42 Feb-09-2010
DEFECTS IN MANUAL WELD STATISTICS

Hello NDT friends.

Does anyone have some link to find a Girth Weld Defects Statistics (number of repaired welds vs. total number of welds) with manual SMAW and GMAW???.
I have found a paper in Welding Journal but focused in Mechanized Field-Welded Pipelines (Wagner and Patchett).

Thank you!!!

    
 
 
Roger Duwe
NDT Inspector, API-510, 570, 653
MISTRAS, USA, Joined Jan 2009, 148

Roger Duwe

NDT Inspector, API-510, 570, 653
MISTRAS,
USA,
Joined Jan 2009
148
22:54 Feb-09-2010
Re: DEFECTS IN MANUAL WELD STATISTICS
In Reply to Carlos at 04:42 Feb-09-2010 (Opening).

Carlos, I was told about 25-30 years ago that a 6-percent reject/repair rate is the upper limit of the norm for SMAW. Anything substantially greater than that is cause for investigation. My experience agrees with that number. GMAW inspected visually VT and radiographically RT should have a little lower reject rate, and ultrasonic UT inspection should give a little higher reject rate than 6 percent [small areas of Lack-of-Fusion]. Pulsed GMAW should have a very low reject rate on everything but the root. If the root is "looked in" by another welder by viewing from the far side of the open root, I am used to seeing a 1-2 percent reject rate.

In the USA, cross-country underground pipelines are typically welded by better-than-average welders, and that reject rate runs about 1-2 percent.

The main item in reject rates is the quality of the welders. With hand-picked welders, it is common to have an entire [small or medium] project with zero rejects.

    
 
 
John O'Brien
Consultant, -
Chevron ETC , USA, Joined Jan 2000, 278

John O'Brien

Consultant, -
Chevron ETC ,
USA,
Joined Jan 2000
278
03:20 Feb-10-2010
Re: DEFECTS IN MANUAL WELD STATISTICS
In Reply to Carlos at 04:42 Feb-09-2010 (Opening).

Good question last year we were researching the same topic and could find little published material. Talking to numerous industry people it seemed 5% was considered the upper limit that people felt was acceptable but that was general. It depends upon application for example we found instances of high quality fatigue sensitive welds with 20% or higher and repairs not permitted.
Some contrcators will quote 2-3% for workmanship criteria increasing to 6-8% for tight ECA based criteria.

    
 
 
Manuel Haces
Director, - Wire rope inspection
Haces Inspección del Noreste and Wire Rope Inspection, Mexico, Joined Jun 2002, 121

Manuel Haces

Director, - Wire rope inspection
Haces Inspección del Noreste and Wire Rope Inspection,
Mexico,
Joined Jun 2002
121
20:25 Feb-10-2010
Re: DEFECTS IN MANUAL WELD STATISTICS
In Reply to Carlos at 04:42 Feb-09-2010 (Opening).

Very good answers, and what we do for quotation of NDT in any jobs, we expect to have as much as 10% in cost regarding repairs of welds and hence re-inspect.

    
 
 

Product Spotlight

SONOAIR - air-coupled Phased Array Ultrasonic Inspection System

For highly attenuating materials, the performance of the system is critical. The ultrasonic sensors,
...
the scanning area and the system settings should be flexibly adapted to the test task and the material. These high expectations are met with the new and modular testing system SONOAIR. With the world’s first air-coupled phased-array UT inspection system SONOAIR we developed a technology that works with up to 4 transmitter and receiver channels with freely configurable square wave burst transmitters as wells as low noise receiving amplifiers.
>

Swift & Scorpion2 - a state-of-the-art remote-control ultrasonic crawler

The Swift and Scorpion2 dry-coupled, remote-access ultrasonic crawler bring major efficiency and d
...
ata improvements to tank shell inspections and other structures such as vessels and offshore installations.
>

Trade-In Offer

We are offering our existing clients trade-in against Wavemaker® G3 systems, Standard (Blue) inflat
...
able rings and modules for excellent deals on the latest Wavemaker® G4mini system.
>

Magnetic X-Ray Pipeline Crawler

Zhong Yi brand pipeline crawler is magnetic/micro-video controlled crawler with DC X ray unit inst
...
alled for checking welding of pipeline. Move steadily inside the pipeline 6''-60''diameter with speed of up to 18m/min, Max. moving diatance 5 kilometers and provide the efficient inspection of the pipeline.
>

Share...
We use technical and analytics cookies to ensure that we will give you the best experience of our website - More Info
Accept
top
this is debug window