where expertise comes together - since 1996

Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)
Open Access Database (Conference Proceedings, Articles, News), Exhibition, Forum, Network

All Forum Boards
Technical Discussions >
Ultrasonic Ispection of Welds in Duplex Steel
Career Discussions
Job Offers
Job Seeks
Classified Ads
About NDT.net
Articles & News

TD NDE
TD NDE. Automated Custom Ultrasonic Robotic and software solutions. Effective, Simple and Flexible solutions to meet your UT needs.

1607 views
03:41 Jan-24-1999
Gordon Allison
Ultrasonic Ispection of Welds in Duplex Steel

Can anyone help me in this subject i.e.

Are there any special equipment required for the UT examination of duplex welds in the past it was not considered possible due to the grain structure but we have a client that insits that it can be inspected and say that there is Equipment on the market.

The welds to be examined are 15mm to 20mm thick
Pressure vessels circumferential welds and nozzle welds.


 
00:35 Jan-26-1999

Rolf Diederichs

Director, Editor, Publisher, Internet, PHP MySQL
NDT.net,
Germany,
Joined Nov 1998
602
Re: Ultrasonic Ispection of Welds in Duplex Steel : Can anyone help me in this subject i.e.

: Are there any special equipment required for the UT examination of duplex welds in the past it was not considered possible due to the grain structure but we have a client that insits that it can be inspected and say that there is Equipment on the market.

: The welds to be examined are 15mm to 20mm thick
: Pressure vessels circumferential welds and nozzle welds.
---------------------------

I hope you found already the below article on NDTnet.

http://www.ndt.net/article/pow1297/schmid/schmid.htm
Ultrasonic Testing of Austenitic and Dissimilar Metal Welds.
By Rudi Schmid. A translated chapter of the German Book: "Ultraschallprüfung von austenitischen Plattierungen, Mischnähten und austenitischen Schweißnähten", Eberhard Neumann et al,.
Rudi Schmid worked with Siemens AG Power Generation Group (KWU) Erlangen
(http://www.ndt.net/exhibit/cust_ky/sie_ky.htm).

Testing of austenitic and dissimilar metal welds is generally limited, since
truly homogeneous ultrasound wave propagation does not exist. The testing and
manufacturing methods must find economical solutions for achieving testability for
those components.
In this chapter the author focus on practical solutions, for instance
Probes and Testing Techniques, Test Results of austenitic Welds, Dissimilar Metal
Welds and Claddings; Comparison of EMAT- SH- and SEL Technique.

Mr. Neumann (Eberhard.Neumann@bam.de) of the BAM Berlin is an outstanding expert in this field.
Mr. Wuestenberg (Hermann.Wuestenberg@bam-berlin.de) is the head of this BAM department and is also on the panel of experts of this forum.
I hope that we get also their comments on this topic.

Rolf



 
04:40 Jan-26-1999
Bjarne Larsen
Re: Ultrasonic Ispection of Welds in Duplex Steel : : Can anyone help me in this subject i.e.

: : Are there any special equipment required for the UT examination of duplex welds in the past it was not considered possible due to the grain structure but we have a client that insits that it can be inspected and say that there is Equipment on the market.

: : The welds to be examined are 15mm to 20mm thick
: : Pressure vessels circumferential welds and nozzle welds.
: ---------------------------

: I hope you found already the below article on NDTnet.

: http://www.ndt.net/article/pow1297/schmid/schmid.htm
: Ultrasonic Testing of Austenitic and Dissimilar Metal Welds.
: By Rudi Schmid. A translated chapter of the German Book: "Ultraschallprüfung von austenitischen Plattierungen, Mischnähten und austenitischen Schweißnähten", Eberhard Neumann et al,.
: Rudi Schmid worked with Siemens AG Power Generation Group (KWU) Erlangen
: (http://www.ndt.net/exhibit/cust_ky/sie_ky.htm).

: Testing of austenitic and dissimilar metal welds is generally limited, since
: truly homogeneous ultrasound wave propagation does not exist. The testing and
: manufacturing methods must find economical solutions for achieving testability for
: those components.
: In this chapter the author focus on practical solutions, for instance
: Probes and Testing Techniques, Test Results of austenitic Welds, Dissimilar Metal
: Welds and Claddings; Comparison of EMAT- SH- and SEL Technique.

: Mr. Neumann (Eberhard.Neumann@bam.de) of the BAM Berlin is an outstanding expert in this field.
: Mr. Wuestenberg (Hermann.Wuestenberg@bam-berlin.de) is the head of this BAM department and is also on the panel of experts of this forum.
: I hope that we get also their comments on this topic.

: Rolf


The welds in duplex steel normally used in the offshore industry is by no means comparable to the austenitic or nickelbase welds, which are known in the nuclear industry. The welds in duplex steel vessels and piping up to a thickness of 70 mm may in many cases be examined with traditional probes and techniques used for the examination of ferritic welds.

It is, however, highly recommendable to perform an accurate measurement of transfer losses including verification of the probe angle on the actual component. Particular attention has to be paid to the state of heat treatment, which may cause considerable changes.

The actual thickness should not cause any problem with 2 MHz angle probes. Normally the attenuation of the material is so low, that even the TOFD technique may be applied as pointed out by Jan Verkoijen.

Regards

Bjarne



 
08:14 Jan-26-1999

Uli Mletzko

R & D, Retired
Germany,
Joined Nov 1998
89
Re: Ultrasonic Ispection of Welds in Duplex Steel : : : Can anyone help me in this subject i.e.

: : : Are there any special equipment required for the UT examination of duplex welds in the past it was not considered possible due to the grain structure but we have a client that insits that it can be inspected and say that there is Equipment on the market.

: : : The welds to be examined are 15mm to 20mm thick
: : : Pressure vessels circumferential welds and nozzle welds.
: : ---------------------------

: : I hope you found already the below article on NDTnet.

: : http://www.ndt.net/article/pow1297/schmid/schmid.htm
: : Ultrasonic Testing of Austenitic and Dissimilar Metal Welds.
: : By Rudi Schmid. A translated chapter of the German Book: "Ultraschallprüfung von austenitischen Plattierungen, Mischnähten und austenitischen Schweißnähten", Eberhard Neumann et al,.
: : Rudi Schmid worked with Siemens AG Power Generation Group (KWU) Erlangen
: : (http://www.ndt.net/exhibit/cust_ky/sie_ky.htm).

: : Testing of austenitic and dissimilar metal welds is generally limited, since
: : truly homogeneous ultrasound wave propagation does not exist. The testing and
: : manufacturing methods must find economical solutions for achieving testability for
: : those components.
: : In this chapter the author focus on practical solutions, for instance
: : Probes and Testing Techniques, Test Results of austenitic Welds, Dissimilar Metal
: : Welds and Claddings; Comparison of EMAT- SH- and SEL Technique.

: : Rolf

:
: The welds in duplex steel normally used in the offshore industry is by no means comparable to the austenitic or nickelbase welds, which are known in the nuclear industry. The welds in duplex steel vessels and piping up to a thickness of 70 mm may in many cases be examined with traditional probes and techniques used for the examination of ferritic welds.

: It is, however, highly recommendable to perform an accurate measurement of transfer losses including verification of the probe angle on the actual component. Particular attention has to be paid to the state of heat treatment, which may cause considerable changes.

: The actual thickness should not cause any problem with 2 MHz angle probes. Normally the attenuation of the material is so low, that even the TOFD technique may be applied as pointed out by Jan Verkoijen.

: Regards

: Bjarne


I think that some of the authors respectively readers are using the terms 'duplex steel' and 'bimetallic weld' in equal sense or meaning. But this is an error as 'duplex steel' absolutely has nothing to do with austenitic or bimetallic (i.e. joint between austenitic and carbon steel) materials. So I think that Bjarne is right and Rolf is wrong (only this time, of course).

Best regards
Uli Mletzko, MPA, University of Stuttgart, Germany




 


© NDT.net - The Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT) ISSN 1435-4934

Open Access Database, |Conference Proceedings| |Articles| |News| |Exhibition| |Forum| |Professional Network|