where expertise comes together - since 1996

Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)
Open Access Database (Conference Proceedings, Articles, News), Exhibition, Forum, Network

All Forum Boards
Technical Discussions >
NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection
Career Discussions
Job Offers
Job Seeks
Classified Ads
About NDT.net
Articles & News

2840 views
01:55 Mar-24-2005
Dean DeLeo
NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection

Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.


 
03:55 Mar-28-2005
DJ Kallhof
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection The crack detection could easily be done with a dry powder mag and an AC yoke. Do not use a DC yoke as it will not allow for particle mobility. I have done similar inspections at a power house construction site that was NRC approved. If you are uneasy with the simplicity of the answer just create a crack sample made of the same material and coat it as thick or thicker than the actual work pieces. Prove your technique to yourself or to the customer. Don't forget the 10 lb weight lift to qualify the yoke.

----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
07:51 Mar-28-2005

Borja Lopez

Director
Innerspec Technologies,
USA,
Joined Jun 2002
35
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
------------ End Original Message ------------

You can do both thickness and weld inspection using Ultrasonic EMAT


 
08:45 Mar-29-2005
Zeki Cosku Gokce
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
------------ End Original Message ------------

Can you give more detail? Can you access both sides of the part also what is the thickness of the part?


 
05:41 Mar-29-2005

Martin Lugg

Consultant,
United Kingdom,
Joined Nov 2000
27
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection The ACFM technique was developed precisely for detecting cracks at welds in carbon steel under non-conducting coatings. In fact, ACFM can detect through much thicker coatings, and can also provide defect sizes.

See our website www.tscinspectionsystems.com for more information.
----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
07:54 Mar-29-2005

J. Mark Davis

Teacher, And Consultant
University of Ultrasonics, Birmingham, Alabama,
USA,
Joined Mar 2000
83
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection What is the thickness of the carbon steel material.

What is the PTFE materail.

What is your critical flaw size?

ID or OD connected cracks are to be detected?

ID or OD Creeping Wave techniques will help with crack detection and qualitative sizing.

J. Mark Davis


----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
: You can do both thickness and weld inspection using Ultrasonic EMAT
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
08:05 Mar-29-2005
Joe Buckley
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection
If the coating is only 50 microns or so it seems unlikely to interfere with most NDT methods, MPI, Eddy current (inc ACFM) and Radiography would barely notice it was there, For UT methods, assuming the coating is well adhering its not much more than a thick layer of couplant. It would always be a good idea to check with a coating gauge that the thickness as you think. for really accurate UT thickness measurement you could apply a correction factor based on the relative velocities, (or just subtract 0.1mm from the indicated reading!)

Exotic methods may be useful for other reasons, But if its just a standard weld a standard method should be enough.
----------- Start Original Message -----------
: Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
05:19 May-09-2005
Dean DeLeo
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection ----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
: Can you give more detail? Can you access both sides of the part also what is the thickness of the part?
------------ End Original Message ------------

Thanks all for the feedback.
The mentioned equipment is a jacketed vessel where the product inside is waxy-like polymer.The internal part of the vessel is coated with 60-micron teflon. The intention is to avoid removing the teflon coating. Unfortunately, the waxy-like polymer is also difficult to remove without damaging the coating.Thus, is there any available NDT technique to do NDT inspection with these parameters in place (teflon+unknown thickness of polymer). The inspection to be conducted is to know the remaining thickness for internal vessel wall (remember the outside is jacketed) and to inspect the integrity of the internal wall's weldment.

Any info would very much appreciated. Thanks.


 
06:48 May-09-2005
D
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection Alternating Current Field Measurement (ACFM) can provide a good quality inspection without removing the coating but it will only detect near surface defects. These methods are used commonly on painted oil rig supports etc with well proven capabilities


 
07:15 May-09-2005

Martin Lugg

Consultant,
United Kingdom,
Joined Nov 2000
27
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection The ACFM technique will be able to inspect the weld surface for cracks through several millimetres of coating. See our web-site for information on performance when inspecting through coatings - and contact details for your local agent.

----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : : Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
: : Can you give more detail? Can you access both sides of the part also what is the thickness of the part?
: Thanks all for the feedback.
: The mentioned equipment is a jacketed vessel where the product inside is waxy-like polymer.The internal part of the vessel is coated with 60-micron teflon. The intention is to avoid removing the teflon coating. Unfortunately, the waxy-like polymer is also difficult to remove without damaging the coating.Thus, is there any available NDT technique to do NDT inspection with these parameters in place (teflon+unknown thickness of polymer). The inspection to be conducted is to know the remaining thickness for internal vessel wall (remember the outside is jacketed) and to inspect the integrity of the internal wall's weldment.
: Any info would very much appreciated. Thanks.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
01:16 May-10-2005

Frank Lund

R & D,
United Kingdom,
Joined Apr 2005
219
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection The electromagnetic array and field gradient imaging techniques offered by NEWT International would be ideal for your application. We have done work through coatings before. Please see our web site or contact sgreenall@lizard.co.uk


----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : : Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
: : Can you give more detail? Can you access both sides of the part also what is the thickness of the part?
: Thanks all for the feedback.
: The mentioned equipment is a jacketed vessel where the product inside is waxy-like polymer.The internal part of the vessel is coated with 60-micron teflon. The intention is to avoid removing the teflon coating. Unfortunately, the waxy-like polymer is also difficult to remove without damaging the coating.Thus, is there any available NDT technique to do NDT inspection with these parameters in place (teflon+unknown thickness of polymer). The inspection to be conducted is to know the remaining thickness for internal vessel wall (remember the outside is jacketed) and to inspect the integrity of the internal wall's weldment.
: Any info would very much appreciated. Thanks.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
01:34 May-10-2005

Joe Buckley

Consultant, ASNT L-III, Honorary Secretary of BINDT
Level X NDT, BINDT,
United Kingdom,
Joined Oct 1999
510
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection I think we need to know a bit more about the thickness of this polymer - "unknown thickness" doesn't give us enough to draw any conclusions from.
Are we talking microns (i.e comparable to the PTFE coating thickness) or significantly more.

Any method / procedure will have a maximum allowable thickness, so you will need to equip yourself with a coating gauge to measure it and be prepared to remove some of the polymer if the thickness is excessive.

Any of the main techniques discussed (UT, ET, ACFM) can 'probably' be applied through coatings of a milimeter or more, but as the coating thickness increases the results will become less reliable.

For UT the propeties of the polymer material will also be important

I think this discussion has progressed to the point where we need more specific information.

Joe

----------- Start Original Message -----------
: : : Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
: : Can you give more detail? Can you access both sides of the part also what is the thickness of the part?
: Thanks all for the feedback.
: The mentioned equipment is a jacketed vessel where the product inside is waxy-like polymer.The internal part of the vessel is coated with 60-micron teflon. The intention is to avoid removing the teflon coating. Unfortunately, the waxy-like polymer is also difficult to remove without damaging the coating.Thus, is there any available NDT technique to do NDT inspection with these parameters in place (teflon+unknown thickness of polymer). The inspection to be conducted is to know the remaining thickness for internal vessel wall (remember the outside is jacketed) and to inspect the integrity of the internal wall's weldment.
: Any info would very much appreciated. Thanks.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 
04:14 May-16-2005

S.V.Swamy

Engineering, - Material Testing Inspection & Quality Control
Retired from Nuclear Fuel Complex ,
India,
Joined Feb 2001
782
Re: NDT for UT measurement and Crack Detection Dear Friends,

I feel that UT is the best bet, assuming that the attentuation in the polymer layer is not too severe. Is there no solvent which helps in removing the polymer without damaging the teflon coating?

Swamy

----------- Start Original Message -----------
: I think we need to know a bit more about the thickness of this polymer - "unknown thickness" doesn't give us enough to draw any conclusions from.
: Are we talking microns (i.e comparable to the PTFE coating thickness) or significantly more.
: Any method / procedure will have a maximum allowable thickness, so you will need to equip yourself with a coating gauge to measure it and be prepared to remove some of the polymer if the thickness is excessive.
: Any of the main techniques discussed (UT, ET, ACFM) can 'probably' be applied through coatings of a milimeter or more, but as the coating thickness increases the results will become less reliable.
: For UT the propeties of the polymer material will also be important
: I think this discussion has progressed to the point where we need more specific information.
: Joe
: : : : Is there any available NDT technique to measure thickness and detect crack on weldment on carbon steel with PTFE coating (50-60 microns) on it? The intention is not to remove the coating to conduct the inspection. Advance thanks for the response.
: : : Can you give more detail? Can you access both sides of the part also what is the thickness of the part?
: : Thanks all for the feedback.
: : The mentioned equipment is a jacketed vessel where the product inside is waxy-like polymer.The internal part of the vessel is coated with 60-micron teflon. The intention is to avoid removing the teflon coating. Unfortunately, the waxy-like polymer is also difficult to remove without damaging the coating.Thus, is there any available NDT technique to do NDT inspection with these parameters in place (teflon+unknown thickness of polymer). The inspection to be conducted is to know the remaining thickness for internal vessel wall (remember the outside is jacketed) and to inspect the integrity of the internal wall's weldment.
: : Any info would very much appreciated. Thanks.
------------ End Original Message ------------




 


© NDT.net - The Web's Largest Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT) ISSN 1435-4934

Open Access Database, |Conference Proceedings| |Articles| |News| |Exhibition| |Forum| |Professional Network|