where expertise comes together - since 1996 -

The Largest Open Access Portal of Nondestructive Testing (NDT)

Conference Proceedings, Articles, News, Exhibition, Forum, Network and more

where expertise comes together
- since 1996 -

GB Inspection Systems Ltd.
A leading UK manufacturer of Ultrasonic Probes, Accessories, Supplier of NDT Equipment and more.

722 views
Technical Discussions
Christian Grosse
Teacher,
Technische Universität München, Germany, Joined Nov 2000, 11

Christian Grosse

Teacher,
Technische Universität München,
Germany,
Joined Nov 2000
11
06:23 Jun-08-1999
The art of discussions

I am writing in response to the comments of Mr. William Streett posted to the NDT forum in the past few weeks, but this contribution is more general so I did not repost it to a certain message. As Rolf Diederichs stated in the introduction to this months forum, if he would "... gave awards for best answers, winners would be Tom Nelligan or Ed Ginzel both are champions! "
I suggest to give the award to Mr. Streett. His answers are always very interesting. For those who did not follow up his contributions, here are some exaples:

To Alex Gibson, 5/21/1999 :
Those engaged in research on impact-echo could benefit from the extensive work done by Professor Sansalone and her colleagues, rather than attempting to reinvent the method.


To Camille Colla, 5/12/1999 :
The article by Colla, et al. is filled with so much misinformation that one hardly knows where to begin ...

Instead of taking the time to learn what is already known ...

They clearly do not understand how the choice of equipment ...

They readily fit the description of unskilled and uninformed operators ...

... has been ignored in the BAM-Berlin article.

To get serious: If someone has arguments against posted articles and think that its contribution to the forum is usefull for others I recomment to stick very close to the scientific details. This is a good tradition in the scientific community and it is even more important in the era of electronic publishing using the internet.
Considering that some of the forum readers with a poor expertise in english (including myself) will not understand the - lets say - enthusiasm of Mr. Streett regarding impact-echo, the scientific content in the sentences citated above is even harder to understand. There is no need to ride a personal attack against somebody else even if there is a dispute in a certain field of application.

Related to the scientific content of Mr. Streett's contributions I want to point out that there is still a lot of work to do in the field of impact-echo techniques. It is undoubtful that not all problems are yet solved especially regarding certain applications. The acceptance of a NDT method is not only influenced by the expertise of the applicators. I am glad about every scientist who is willing to share the results of impact-echo measurements and who gives details about measurement techniques and equipment. Reviewing the research in similar fields in the past it becomes obvious, that a method is developed much faster and more efficient if some different research groups with different equipment are working on theory and applications. Sometimes there are more benefits using own equipment than using the black-box equipment of a comercial manufacturer, but I agree that a company representative may have another opinion ;-)

Sorry, for my lengthy non-scientific contribution - maybe this is the time to come back to research and some concise discussions about it.



    
 
 
Michael Trinidad
Consultant,
LMATS Pty Ltd , Australia, Joined Jan 2003, 138

Michael Trinidad

Consultant,
LMATS Pty Ltd ,
Australia,
Joined Jan 2003
138
01:53 Jun-09-1999
Re: The art of discussions
On the other hand the beauty of this particular site is that participating authors answer posted questions in a pertinent, precise yet they can deliver the information in basic terminology.

Most posts stimulate discussion and discussions provide an invaluable learning tool and I have collected some interesting bits of information which I file away for future reference.

I hope the forum stays the same, a site where questions can be asked by beginners or scientists and anything in between and worded in a fashion all can benefit from.

Kind Regards

Michael Trinidad



    
 
 

Product Spotlight

SONOAIR - air-coupled Phased Array Ultrasonic Inspection System

For highly attenuating materials, the performance of the system is critical. The ultrasonic sensors,
...
the scanning area and the system settings should be flexibly adapted to the test task and the material. These high expectations are met with the new and modular testing system SONOAIR. With the world’s first air-coupled phased-array UT inspection system SONOAIR we developed a technology that works with up to 4 transmitter and receiver channels with freely configurable square wave burst transmitters as wells as low noise receiving amplifiers.
>

Echomac® PA Rail Wheel Tester

MAC introduces two versions of Rail Wheel Testers using ECHOMAC® PA platform based on customer requ
...
irements.
>

TVC awarded UKAS accreditation

TVC are delighted to finally announce we have been awarded UKAS accreditation for our calibration
...
laboratory. Laboratory accreditation to ISO/IEC 17025:2005 enables us to conduct the Electrical Verification of Ultrasonic Flaw Detection Equipment to BS EN 12668-1:2010. It has taken many months of hard work and we want to thank our staff for all their efforts during this massive undertaking.
>

Ultrasonic Testing Immersion Tanks with Unmatched Scanning Features

TecScan’s non-destructive testing Ultrasonic Immersion Tanks & scanners are designed for high pe
...
rformance and demanding NDT testing applications. Our Scan3D™ line of High Precision Immersion Tanks are specifically designed for automated ultrasonic testing of complex composites parts used in aerospace and industrial applications.
>

Share...
We use technical and analytics cookies to ensure that we will give you the best experience of our website - More Info
Accept
top
this is debug window